Index funds
·
4 min read
What is a small-cap stock?
How small caps have compared with large caps, and why the index your fund tracks can change your result
How companies are grouped by size
One common way to group companies is by size. The groups are mega-cap, large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and micro-cap.
The “cap” is short for market capitalization, which is just the total dollar value of a company’s shares. You find it by taking the share price and multiplying it by the number of shares. A company’s market capitalization is the figure that places it in one of these size groups.
A small-cap stock is generally a company worth roughly $300 million to $2 billion.¹ Large-cap starts around $10 billion.¹ The biggest companies, like Apple or Microsoft, are over $1 trillion.¹
These ranges vary by index provider, so you’ll see different cutoffs in different places. One index provider may set the line between small-cap and mid-cap at a different point than another provider does. When you read about small caps, the size range behind the label depends on the index provider.
How small caps compare with large caps
Now a common question. How have small caps performed in the past compared to large caps?
Since 1979, when the Russell 2000 started tracking small-caps, it has roughly matched the S&P 500, slightly ahead over the whole stretch. Over that full period, small caps and large caps have ended up in a similar place.
Over the last decade though, the S&P 500 has done better. Since the end of 2013, the S&P 500 returned about 260 percent while the Russell 2000 returned about 110 percent.²
The small-cap index has not beaten the S&P 500 in a calendar year since 2020. The S&P 500 has come out ahead in each calendar year since then.
So the answer depends on the time frame you look at. Since 1979, the two indexes are close, with the Russell 2000 slightly ahead. Over the last decade, the S&P 500 has been ahead.
Why these swings run in long stretches
That last decade is not the whole story, though, because these swings run in long stretches. One part of the market can lead for years, and then the other part can take over for years.
Small-caps outperformed large-caps through the financial crisis and the recovery after it. Large-caps outperformed from 2014 to 2020. Small-caps outperformed in the year after the pandemic crash. And large-caps have led for much of the time since.
Those cycles run for years, which means anyone can point at a period that proves their point. Someone who favors small caps can point to the financial crisis and the recovery after it, or to the year after the pandemic crash. Someone who favors large caps can point to 2014 to 2020, or to the last decade. Each period is real, but one period on its own does not tell the whole story.
Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Diversification and small-company risk
So what can you take from this?
Not that small-caps are a better bet. They behave differently, and that is the argument for holding some.
When large-caps struggle, small-caps sometimes do not, and the reverse. Holding both means you are not dependent on one part of the market working. That is diversification, and it is a different argument from expecting higher returns. The argument for holding some small caps is how they behave next to large caps, not an expectation of higher returns.
The other thing to know is that small companies are riskier individually. They fail more often and have less cash to survive a bad year. Small-cap returns swing harder in both directions. In a good stretch, small-cap returns can rise more sharply. In a bad stretch, they can fall more sharply, and a single small company can go through a bad year with less cash to fall back on.
Which small-cap index your fund tracks
One more thing, and it matters. Which small-cap index you pick can change your result, even inside the same asset class.
The S&P SmallCap 600 requires companies to have positive earnings to be added. The Russell 2000 does not. Both are small-cap indexes, but they use different rules to decide which small companies get in. The S&P SmallCap 600 adds a company only if it has positive earnings, while the Russell 2000 can include companies without them.
Over one measured period, a dollar in the S&P 600 grew to $8.59 while the same dollar in the Russell 2000 grew to $6.18.² Both figures start from the same dollar over the same period.
Same asset class, different rules, meaningfully different outcome. Worth knowing which one your fund tracks.
The popular funds are IWM and VTWO, which follow the Russell 2000, and IJR and SCHA, which follow other small-cap indexes with different construction rules.
What Advizmo does
Advizmo invests your cash to diversify across funds, harvest tax losses,³ and sell in a tax-smart way when you need cash for life events.³
¹ Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee.
² Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results.
³ Not tax advice. Individual results vary.
All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Advizmo advisory fee and subscription apply. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876).
