Cash flow
·
4 min read
Setting your monthly transfer amount
Why a fixed monthly transfer can make your money math harder, not easier
You hear a lot about automating your investing. But that set amount you move every month? A lot of the time it makes your money math harder, not easier. Auto-investing a fixed amount every month is a decent forcing mechanism. But I don’t think it removes any work. You still run the calculations, and you still work out whether checking covers your bills. This post looks at where that work goes when the amount is fixed, and what changes when the amount comes from your upcoming balances and bills.
A fixed amount as a forcing mechanism
You hear a lot about automating your investing. The usual version of that advice is to pick a set amount and move it every month. I think that is a decent forcing mechanism. The money leaves your checking account on a schedule, and it goes toward your investments without you deciding again each month. That part works.
But I don’t think it removes any work. A forcing mechanism moves the money. It does not do the thinking that comes before the money moves. You are the one who picked the number. You are the one who decides whether that number still fits this month. And the schedule does not know what your month looks like.
So the set amount is doing one job. It moves a fixed number on a fixed date. Everything around that number is still yours to work out. That is the part of automating your investing I want to look at, because a lot of the time that set amount makes your money math harder, not easier. Moving the money on its own is one thing. Moving the work off your plate is another, and the fixed amount only does the first one.
The math you still do each month
You still have to do your calculations every month, or each time you get paid. That is true whether you are paid once a month or more often. Money comes in. Bills are coming up. You look at your checking balance and work out whether it covers what is due. That part was there before you automated anything.
Now there is one more piece in it. When you check whether you have enough in checking to cover your bills, you also have to remember that set amount getting invested. It is leaving on its own date, whether or not this month lines up with the number you picked. So you are not only checking your balance against your bills. You are checking your balance against your bills and the transfer.
That is more mental math, not less. And there is a second effect. When you are not sure how the timing will land, the safer move is to keep extra money sitting in checking. So you are probably leaving cash sitting idle just to be safe. The transfer went out on schedule, and a cushion stayed behind in your checking account. The fixed amount moved itself, and the balancing work stayed with you.
Moving the right amount at each payday
One approach is to automatically move the right amount each time you get paid, based on your upcoming balances and bills. The amount is not picked once and left alone. It comes from what is in your accounts and what is coming due.
Two things follow from that. Less cash sits idle, because the cushion is set by your bills rather than by a number chosen in advance. And more of your funds are put to work for you instead of waiting in checking against a bill that a fixed number could not see.
There is also the pulling together. That part usually means logging into multiple accounts to gather your balances and your upcoming bills so you can compare them. In this approach you don’t have to log into multiple accounts to pull everything together, your balances, your upcoming bills. The gathering happens for you.
Then the calculations happen automatically. The account is designed to keep enough cash in checking to cover your bills, and the rest moves into high-yield savings, money market funds, and investments automatically. The order is worth noting. Bills are covered first out of the calculation, and what is left after that is what moves. The bills lead, and the transfer follows.
What Advizmo is designed to do
That’s what Advizmo is designed for. It pulls in your balances and upcoming bills, does the calculations, is designed to keep enough in checking to cover your bills, and moves the rest into high-yield savings, money market funds, and investments, automatically. The amount comes from your upcoming balances and bills rather than from a fixed number set once. No spreadsheets. Less guessing. Just your money, put to work.
Check out Advizmo. Link in bio.
Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee. Not tax advice. Individual results vary. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Advizmo advisory fee and subscription apply. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876).
