Index funds
·
5 min read
Six small-cap indexes, six ways to pick companies
Different rules, different stocks, and different returns behind funds that are all called small-cap
When someone says they bought a small-cap fund, ask which index it tracks. Many fund buyers may not know. That question matters. The difference starts with the index each fund follows. This post walks through six small-cap indexes used by US funds, ranging from about 600 to about 2,000 stocks.
The Russell 2000 index. No profitability filter.
The first index is the Russell 2000. It holds about 2,000 stocks. It takes the companies ranked 1,001 through 3,000 by size and includes them all. There is no profitability filter, so a company does not need to earn a profit to be in it. Funds that track it include IWM, VTWO, and FSSNX.
The S&P SmallCap 600 index screens for profitability
The second index is the S&P SmallCap 600. It holds about 600 stocks. A committee maintains it, and companies must have positive earnings to be added. That means it screens for profitability at the door, before a company gets in. Funds that track it include SPSM, IJR, and VIOO.
Both are called small-cap indexes. The Russell 2000 includes all the companies in its size range, while the S&P SmallCap 600 checks for positive earnings first.
The CRSP index uses percentage bands of market value
The third is the CRSP US Small Cap index. It holds about 1,400 stocks. Instead of a fixed company count, it uses percentage bands of total market value. It also moves stocks between size categories gradually instead of all at once. Vanguard uses this index, and the fund is VB.
The Dow Jones index carves small-cap from the total market
The fourth is the Dow Jones US Small-Cap Total Stock Market index. It holds about 1,700 stocks. It carves small-cap out of a total market index by market value. The aim is broad coverage of the whole small-cap segment. Schwab uses this index, and the fund is SCHA.
Both of these indexes start from total market value. CRSP turns it into percentage bands, and Dow Jones uses it to carve small-cap out of a total market index. The small-cap label is the same, but each index draws its lines in its own way.
The Morningstar index draws its own size bands
The fifth is the Morningstar US Small Cap index. It holds about 1,500 stocks. Morningstar draws its own size bands off total market value. It also has rules about when a company moves between those bands. iShares uses this index for a different fund than IWM, and that fund is ISCB.
The MSCI index uses its own global framework
The sixth is the MSCI USA Small Cap index. It holds about 1,700 stocks. MSCI uses its own global framework and applies it consistently across countries. That makes it more common in institutional portfolios than in retail ones. The widely traded iShares version is ESML, and it adds an ESG screen on top of the index.
That makes six indexes, all called small-cap, each with its own rules for which companies belong. The stock counts alone run from about 600 in the S&P SmallCap 600 to about 2,000 in the Russell 2000.
Each index answers the same question differently
So why does this matter to you? Each index answers the same question differently. That question has four parts.
First, where does small-cap start and stop? Second, how many companies belong in it? Third, does a company have to be profitable to get in? Fourth, how quickly do stocks move in and out?
The six indexes give six different sets of answers. One index may include all the companies in a size range. Another may check for positive earnings first. Another may draw its own size bands off total market value. Another may move stocks between size categories gradually.
That means two funds can both be called small-cap and charge nearly the same fee. They can hold many of the same companies. They can still deliver different results. The label on the fund can be the same while the rules underneath it are different.
What an index choice can do over time
Here is what that looks like in practice. Over one measured period, a dollar in the S&P SmallCap 600 grew to $8.59.* The same dollar in the Russell 2000 grew to $6.18.*
Same asset class, different rules. The gap between the two came largely from the profitability screen. That is the rule that requires positive earnings at the door. The S&P SmallCap 600 has that screen, and the Russell 2000 does not.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. That gap is not typical of all periods, and it can run the other direction. In another period, the result between these two indexes could look different.
But it shows the size of what an index choice can do over time, even inside one asset class. Both indexes carry the same small-cap label, and the rules each one uses to decide what to own are different.
Picking a fund means picking an index
So when you pick a small-cap fund, you are also picking an index. The fund delivers whatever the index says to own. If the index screens for profitability, the fund holds the companies that pass the screen. If the index includes about 2,000 companies by rank, the fund holds those.
That is why the question at the start of this post matters. When someone says they bought a small-cap fund, ask which index it tracks. The answer points to which companies the fund holds, how many there are, and how they move in and out.
For many investors, the choice often narrows to three. Those three are the Russell 2000, the S&P SmallCap 600, and one of the broad ones like CRSP or Dow Jones. Each one answers the small-cap question in its own way, with its own rules and its own set of stocks.
Cash, budgeting, and investing in one place
Just getting started investing, or looking to automate it? Advizmo manages your cash, your budgeting, and your investing in one place, all tax-smart.** Cash, budgeting, and investing are three parts of your money, and Advizmo brings them together.
