Taxes
·
5 min read
How tax-loss harvesting works in a dip
What happens to your taxes when a position dips, and why market swings can create more chances to harvest
If you’re not tax-loss harvesting, you’re leaving money on the table. A lot of investing attention goes to the question of what to buy. Less of it goes to what happens to the investments already held when their prices move. Tax-loss harvesting sits in that second group. This post covers what it is, what happens when a position falls below what was paid for it, and why the number of chances to use it changes with the market.
Where investing attention tends to go
People spend a lot of time trying to figure out what stocks to buy. Which company to own. Which name to add next. The question comes back around often.
A lot of the time, that is reading headlines and debating, rather than research. Headlines are easy to reach. The debate is easy to join. What comes out of it is a view on a company, and the view may or may not hold.
Tax optimization takes up less of that attention. Tax-loss harvesting sits in that group, along with other tax optimization strategies. For some investors, these may add more value than picking stocks.
That points toward a different question. Instead of asking which stock to buy next, an investor can look at what happens to the holdings already in the account when prices move. Prices move on their own. The tax treatment of those moves is something that can be acted on.
The rest of this post stays with that second question. What tax-loss harvesting is. What happens when a position dips. How volatility changes the number of chances to use it. And what consistent investing has to do with the result.
What happens when a position dips
When a position dips, that can be an opportunity. The price of an investment falls below what was paid for it. At that point, a loss exists in the account.
Tax-loss harvesting is selling investments at a loss to reduce taxable income and offset gains. The loss from the position that fell is applied against gains made elsewhere in the portfolio. Use that loss to offset gains elsewhere. The taxable amount comes down.
A smaller taxable amount means less tax owed on those gains. Less paid in tax leaves more of the return in the account. That is where the potential for lower taxes and higher after-tax returns comes from. The return before tax and the return after tax are two different numbers, and the second one is what the investor keeps.
A dip on its own is a drop in value. The account is worth less than it was before. Tax-loss harvesting does not change that part. What it does is take a loss that has already happened and apply it against the tax owed on gains.
The loss and the tax treatment of the loss are separate things. One is the market. The other is the return the investor keeps after taxes.
Volatility and the number of chances to harvest
The more volatile the market, the more opportunities can show up. Volatility is price movement. Prices swing up and down across a period rather than moving in a straight line.
More swings mean more moments when a position sits below what was paid for it. Those are the moments tax-loss harvesting works with. More swings. More chances to harvest. More potential tax harvesting opportunities.
A quiet market produces fewer of those moments. When prices move a little, positions stay closer to what was paid for them, and there is less available to apply against gains. A market that moves a lot produces the opposite. The same portfolio, across a period with more movement, can present more points where a loss is available to use.
That is one way to look at a period of market swings. The swings are still swings. The account value moves with them. The number of chances to apply a loss against gains moves with them as well.
And the more volatile it gets, the more valuable it may become. The strategy stays the same. What changes is the number of times it can be applied across the year.
Consistency instead of timing the market
Timing the market is difficult to do consistently. Buying ahead of a rise and selling ahead of a fall calls for knowing what comes next, over and over.
One approach is to keep investing consistently. Money goes in on a schedule rather than when a moment looks right. The question of when leaves the process, and the contributions continue through periods when prices fall.
The lows aren’t just losses. They can also be tax breaks. A period of falling prices lowers the account value. That same period produces the positions sitting below what was paid for them, which is where harvesting starts.
Investors who invest consistently stay invested, compared with those who skip making investments because they didn’t prioritize it. Investing consistently does not remove the risk of loss.
Research says this could be an additional 1% in after-tax returns per year.¹ And the more volatile it gets, the more valuable it may become. That figure sits alongside the market return rather than replacing it, and it comes from the tax side of the account.
What Advizmo is built to do
That is what Advizmo is built for. It is built to keep you investing consistently, automate your tax-loss harvesting, and is designed to use market dips in a tax-smart way to keep your portfolio working.
Consistent investing and tax-loss harvesting run inside the same account rather than as two separate tasks. The harvesting runs on the positions in the portfolio when prices move, without the investor tracking each one.
Check out Advizmo. Link in bio.
¹ Chaudhuri, Burnham, and Lo, Financial Analysts Journal, 2020; Vanguard Research. Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results.
Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee. Not tax advice. Individual results vary. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Advizmo advisory fee and subscription apply. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876).
