Getting started
·
4 min read
Budgeting and investing. Two different skills
Why the control that makes you good at budgeting can work against you when you invest
At Advizmo we meet a lot of people who are excellent at budgeting but haven’t done much investing. One of the key reasons is not laziness. It is that budgeting and investing require different mindsets.
Budgeting is the first step
Budgeting is the first step for many people, and it can be difficult. If you do not spend less than you earn, nothing else in personal finance is available to you. No investing, no compounding, no retirement account. There is no money to work with. That is why the budget comes before everything else.
Put another way, spending less than you earn is what opens the door to the rest. Investing needs money to invest. Compounding needs money that can earn over time. A retirement account needs money going into it. Without money left over, none of those can start.
So if you budget well, you did the thing that makes everything else possible. The people we meet at Advizmo who are excellent at budgeting have already done this part. A good budget is what creates the money that investing, compounding, and a retirement account need.
A good budget creates idle cash
But it creates a new problem. A good problem. It is a problem that only shows up after the budgeting work is done.
You now have idle cash, a sign the budget is working. And money sitting in checking can lose purchasing power when prices rise and your balance does not. The balance stays where it is while prices move up.
So the next step is putting that money to work, where it can earn and compound over time. Budgeting got the money into your account. Investing is how that money can start to earn. Leaving it in checking means it stays idle.
This is where some people get stuck. Because budgeting and investing take different mindsets. Getting good at one does not make you good at the other. The habits that helped you build the balance are not the same habits that help you invest it.
Budgeting is control, investing is handing it over
Budgeting is about control. You decide where every dollar goes. You track it. You know the balance. If something is off, you can see it and correct it this week. The whole skill is control and visibility, and getting good at it means getting good at those. When you budget, you are in charge of what happens next.
With investing you hand the money over. You cannot control what it does. Some months it goes down, and there is nothing to correct, because nothing is broken. You have to sit there and not act, which is the opposite of the instinct that made you good at budgeting. You are not in charge of what the money does from month to month.
So it is not a coincidence that careful budgeters can find investing uncomfortable. The skill that got you here is working against you at the next step.
What makes investing feel hard
There are a few other things that make it feel hard.
People will tell you investing is risky, and over short periods they are right. Money in checking feels safe by comparison. Some months an investment goes down, and that is part of why it is called risky.
And investing can feel unfamiliar. You know where your checking account is and how to get money out of it. Anything new feels like a step into the dark. An investment account is a new place for your money.
But here is the thing to hold onto. Millions of people invest. This is not an exotic activity for specialists. It is ordinary, and you are not the only person who found the first step uncomfortable.
You just need to get started. And it is completely fine to start small and go slow. The first step does not need to be a large one.
What the money is for
One more thing about what this is for. Investing is not only about the far future.
The goal is to have enough for a decent retirement, while also being able to enjoy life along the way. Take the trip. Buy the thing that makes your life better. Money that is working for you can help make both of those possible at the same time. Retirement is the long-term part. The trip and the thing that makes your life better are the part along the way. The goal includes both, not one or the other.
The takeaway. If you’re great at budgeting and haven’t started investing, you’re not failing. You’re good at a skill that demands control, but you’re being asked to do something that requires letting go. Knowing that is much of the battle. Start small.
How Advizmo works with idle cash
Advizmo can help with this, the step from budgeting to investing. Opening an account and making your first investment is straightforward. After that you can automate it. Advizmo does the calculations for you, identifying idle cash while aiming to keep enough in checking to cover your upcoming bills. And when you need cash for a life event, Advizmo manages the sale in a tax-smart way.*
*Not tax advice. Individual results vary.
Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee.
All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Advizmo advisory fee and subscription apply. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876).
