Taxes
·
5 min read
What a market drop can mean at tax time
How tax loss harvesting works and why the timing matters.
A market drop is a loss. It can also be a tax break. That second part is what this post covers. It is not about buying the dip, and it is not about going to cash. It is a tax strategy, it is legal, and it works on positions that are already down. The question is what it is, how it works, and why the timing of it matters. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.
What tax loss harvesting is
A market drop pulls the value of a portfolio down. That much is plain. What sits underneath it is a tax strategy, and it is worth separating from two other ideas that come up when the market falls.
It is not about buying the dip. Adding money to a falling market is a separate decision. It is not about going to cash either. Selling out and waiting on the sidelines is also a separate decision. This is neither of those.
It is a tax strategy that can turn a bad market day into a financial advantage. It is legal. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.
The name for it is tax loss harvesting. The idea is tax-smart. Rather than treating a down day as something to sit through, it treats the loss on a position as something with a use. That use is on your tax return.
It works inside an existing portfolio. The amount invested stays the same. The market exposure stays the same. The work happens on the positions already sitting at a loss, and on what those losses can do against the taxes owed for the year.
How the loss gets used
When a portfolio drops, some positions are sitting at a loss. Not the whole account, and not on the same day for each holding. Some positions are down, and those are the ones this applies to.
Instead of just holding and waiting, the loss gets used. Those positions are sold. The loss is locked in on paper. Then the money is reinvested in something similar, so the money stays in the market.
That loss can offset gains elsewhere. It can reduce what is owed to the IRS for the year. Not tax advice. Individual results vary.
The reinvestment step is what keeps the account invested. Selling and stopping there would leave the money in cash. Selling and reinvesting in something similar keeps the exposure in place while the loss is recorded. The market can rise or fall from there. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.
There is a window on this. The loss exists while the position is down. Once the position turns green again, the loss is gone, and so is the tax break attached to it. That is the part of tax loss harvesting that runs on the calendar of the market rather than on a schedule of your own.
What the numbers show
Research puts the value at around 1 percent in additional after tax returns per year.¹ That is a research figure for the practice, not a figure from a single account.
Applied to a $50,000 portfolio over 30 years, that 1 percent works out to over $200,000. Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.
The figure does not come from better picks. It does not come from choosing which stocks or funds will rise. The holdings can be the same either way.
It comes from a system running in the background when the market gets volatile. Volatility creates positions sitting at a loss. Those losses are what the strategy works with. A market that moves gives the system something to work on. A market that sits still gives it less.
Compounding is doing work in that number as well. A 1 percent difference in a single year is small. The figure above assumes it repeats across 30 years, on a portfolio that stays invested through that period. Whether a given portfolio matches that pattern is a separate question. Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee. Not tax advice. Individual results vary.
Timing is the catch
The catch is timing. The move comes before the recovery.
That is a narrow requirement. A position that is down today may be back up next week. Once it is back up, there is no loss to record, and the opportunity that was there is closed. The strategy depends on acting while the position is still down.
Two things get in the way of that. Some people do not know this exists. An opportunity that is not known about is not acted on, and the window closes on its own.
Others know about it and move too slowly. Checking a portfolio position by position takes time. Deciding what to sell takes time. Finding something similar to reinvest in takes time. Markets can recover faster than a manual review can be finished.
That is why the timing question is a practical one rather than a knowledge one. Knowing the strategy and acting on it inside the window are two different things. A down market does not stay down on a schedule that suits a weekly or monthly review. The opportunity appears when the market moves, and it closes when the market moves back.
How Advizmo runs this
Advizmo is built to run this process for you. When a harvestable opportunity appears in a portfolio, the system is designed to identify it, sell the position, and reinvest to keep the account in the market. The steps described above are carried out by the system rather than by a manual review. The design goal is that the process runs without the account holder touching anything. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876). All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.
Link in bio to see how Advizmo works.
¹ Chaudhuri, Burnham, and Lo, Financial Analysts Journal, 2020; Vanguard Research.
Estimates only. Review before investing. Not a guarantee. Not tax advice. Individual results vary. Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Advizmo advisory fee and subscription apply. Advizmo is an SEC-registered investment adviser (File No. 801-133876).
